Neutrogena Hydrating Eye Makeup Remover Lotion, Gentle Daily Makeup Remover with Skin-Soothing Aloe and Cucumber Extracts to Remove Even Waterproof Mascara, Fragrance-Free, 3 oz

O.K. Let me start by saying I have extremely sensitive skin. My eyes are even,more sensitive than the rest of my sensitive skin. A great portion of new things I try,dor,me eyes ends up getting thrown or returned right away because of allergic reaction that could last 1-3 days. I found a great eye makeup remover about 10 years ago that I loved. Several months ago it was discontinued and I was really worried that I would have a difficult time finding a replacement. I tried aa couple of "all natural" products and another liquidy remover. I was pretty allergic to one and I did not like the watery consistency of the other one. I started a big search and finally found that Neutrogena had a lotion-like eye makeup remover!! I had no idea as I use a ton of Neutrogena products but had never seen this particular one. I bought it a couple of weeks ago. I waited to write a review until I had used it multiple times. I feel so lucky to have found this product! It's excellent. The consistency is great, it doesn't take a ton to remove a good amount of makeup and most important to me, it is extremely gentle. My eyes feel great after I use it and I haven't had even the slightest bit of irritation since beginning to use. If you have extremely sensitive eyes and like a thicker product to remove eye makeup, I would seriously give this one a try!!

I love this product, but can not condone spending $69 for a 3 oz tube. How is it possible to charge that kind of amount?

This lotion is EVERYTHING! At the ripe old age of 30, I've started noticing fine lines reproducing like bunnies under my eyes and over my cheek bones. I decided I needed something more gentle to remove my stubborn eye make up so I didn't have to rub and tug at the most delicate areas of skin on my face. In the past I've shied away from make up removers, even those marketed at oil-free because they tend to feel greasy and leave a residue on my already oily, acne prone skin. This lotion however checks all the boxes. It's smooth and gentle on my eyes, requires little to no harsh rubbing, leaves no slimy residue, and doesn't cause breakouts. It's so gentle, in fact, that I can open my eyes when the product is still on my face and am faced with no excruciating burning or irritation in my eyes. Also, it's so effective at removing my eye make up that I often smooth the excess over the rest of my face and let it melt away my foundation/concealer/contour as well. Just a heads up, you are going to want to use a nice soft wash cloth in conjunction with this product, however, because water alone isn't going to rinse this away. Again, you don't have to rub with the cloth, just gently wipe away the product and be amazed at how make-up free and hydrated your face is afterwards!

I have been looking for a good eye makeup remover for months. I have used all the liquid products and even the micellar products, but always felt that they are too thin to actually remove the eye makeup without more effort than I would like. I've also tried to makeup remover cloths alone (but I end up rubbing quite a while on my eyes and working too hard to get off the mascara); and microfiber cloths that only require water, and while they may be okay for face makeup, you still have to tug on your eyelids to get the eye makeup off, so those failed, too. With this tube of remover cream, I use a small amount (probably pea-sized) for each eye, and I do work it into my eyelashes for about 20 seconds, then finish with a makeup remover cloth, and the mascara comes right off. It is very creamy and moisturizing, and tho' it does sting a little, it's not as much as other eye makeup remover products. I am glad I found this and will continue to use it. You should definitely try it if you're not happy with other products!

Like you, I really rely on these reviews to help me choose a product. I wanted makeup remover to go with the microfiber clothes I had purchased (can't remove eye make up on their own). I was tired of the makeup remover wipes that dry out my skin.I squeeze some of this out onto the cloth, rub it around a bit, and then wipe my eyes. It takes off my eye shadow, liner, and NOT waterproof mascara just fine with little effort. My water resistant eye liner is a little tougher but can still come off. I've been playing around with different quantities but so far it doesn't seem to take much. I don't use water proof mascara so can't say how that works.I have very sensitive skin and eyes and this has not irritated me at all. I do keep my eyes closed and wipe again with a clean wet section of my cloth before opening them.A little pricey for my taste - but I'll see how long it lasts.

I don’t often give five-star reviews. My socks have to be knocked off for that. Listen, this is a new holy grail product for me and it gets five stars! It took off all my caked on eye makeup with a small pea-sized amount per eye and wiped off with a tissue. I had on heavy dark eye shadow and three coats of mascara, and it’s all gone. None of that filmy mess under my eyes, it’s all gone. I’m kicking myself for not taking a picture. I did get a little in one eye that burned a little bit, but I expected much worse, and it went away after a few seconds without rinsing. Otherwise, my eyes are not oily, not dry, and without traces of makeup that need to be cleaned up. (This is so lazy...) I didn’t even wash my face. Used wipes on the rest of my face, smeared on a little lotion, I’m good to go! My skin is happy, and I am happy!