Honest BeautyLonglasting Liquid Eyeliner | Smudge + Flake Proof, Precise Application | Hypoallergenic, Vegan, + Cruelty Free | Black, 0.58 fl oz

I have used eyeliner pens for years. I was nervous to try a liquid eyeliner because I thought it would be difficult to apply. I am happy to report that I was mistaken - this liquid eyeliner is way easier to use that the pens I’ve been using for ten years. I only regret that it took me so long to make the switch. My only complaint is that it smears easily when my eyes tear up or water. I know it’s not supposed to be waterproof, but it doesn’t last as long as other non waterproof eyeliners. I don’t mind it though because I can easily wipe off the smudged part and reapply.

I love this eyeliner. It might be the first liquid eyeliner I’ve ever used that doesn’t smudge by the end of the day. I originally bought it because it is EWG approved with only the safest ingredients. I won’t ever use another eyeliner!

I used this item for a year after switching from Maybelline. It delivers a similiar result and I enjoyed using it. However, the price is about double. I had some extra to put towards better ingredients and better animal treatment for a while. I am switching back to maybelline now because of cost.

I absolutely love this stuff. It goes on smooth, dries fast, and doesn't smudge. I wear this from 5am to 9pm and it still looks great. Just bought my second one! I love knowing it is free of the nasty stuff, and safer to use.I really didn't know if I'd like the applicator, but it's actually fine.

This liner is perfect for getting that sharp wing, but it does smear if it gets a bit wet like from your eyes tearing or even applying setting spray. So it’s a bit of a small thing to get passed

I was looking for a more natural eyeliner that isn't waterproof, and I landed on Honest Company. I don't think I'll buy my eyeline or mascara anywhere else! It doesn't smear, it's easy to use and lasts all day.

Second time I’ve tried this product. Had eye sensitivity and puffiness and didn’t think it was necessarily the product. Tried it again, brand new, after 6 months, no eye issues, and the first hour I had puffy eyes, swelling, and drainage the next morning after wearing. Will not be buying again!

This and the Honest mascara are the only ones that don't irritate my very sensitive eyes.I freaking love this brand and love this type of eyeliner that dips.This dries quickly and doesn’t smudge or run easily. Very early to apply.