SmashboxAlways On Gel Liner

What a great eye liner It stays on all day and doesn’t smudge Just love this product

I love the color of this eyeliner so much but very disappointed in the quality of the product. The pencil has to be sharpened pretty often as it wears down quickly and the way it is designed it keeps sticking the eye which is annoying and uncomfortable. Smashbox needs to improve on the quality of the pencil itself. In another packaging, the color is bomb.

I have watery eyes so I had a hard time finding the right eyeliner, this one stays till I take offThe only bad thing is that I have to sharpen it constantly,

The reason I'm giving this 4 stars instead of 5 is because of how difficult it is to sharpen it without it breaking off. I have the Brewed color and it's a true brown which is very nice. The gel liner goes on easily and usually lasts all day. If I go out for the evening I need to reapply, otherwise just applying in the morning is sufficient for the work day. I wear contacts and this product doesn't bother them, or me, at all. The only issue I have is the sharpening. I'm not sure if it's me or the pencil but it breaks all the time when I'm sharpening it! It doesn't matter if I do is fast or slow, big sharpener or small... I can't win. I ordered the Always Sharp version instead (it's the self sharpening one).

Love the way this eyeliner stays put for a very long time. I have watery eyes due to allergies, but it lasts a long time in place for me. It also goes on very smoothly. Highly recommend!

Fine at first until.you need it sharpened