Honeybee GardensEffortless Eyeliner Pencil in Belgian Chocolate, Rich Pigmentation, Smooth, Long-Wearing, Vegan, Gluten-Free

I really do love this eyeliner. I was hesitant to try it but for the price I could not pass it up and it is one of my favorites. First off I love the color is not to dark and not to light. Secondly it goes on so easy for a pencil. It works like a crayon except you sharpen it like a pencil. It stays on really well if you let it dry a minute before it hits the wetness of your eye. It is easy to clean off when I wash my face and the price was great. I will be getting other colors in this eyeliner and recommend you try it for yourself.

Very light black color which is perfect for the lower lids. No sensitivity and sharpens well.

I bought this in the hope that it would not irritate my eyes and it doesn’t. Most eye makeup does to some extent or another. I also got the mascara.Pros: doesn’t irritate my eyes. Goes on very smoothly...the softest eyeliner I’ve ever used. It’s a really nice slightly greenish rich navy that makes my eyes look a bit bluer.Cons: the flip side of it being so soft is that you have to be very careful not to smudge it everywhere. I put powder under it, blend it with a small brush, then put powder over it. It stays put that way.Long-term update: I got really tired of how badly it smudged and got under my eyes and quit using it. Only buy if you are a total pro at keeping things put.

Great length of a pencil, good quality eyeliner. It’s glides softly and it lasts all day.

I've been looking for a replacement eyeliner since they stopped making my favorite. This is the one! It goes on smoothly without pulling, it doesn't smudge, washes off easily and is a very dark plum color. It also sharpens easily with my regular sharpener. I'll definitely buy again.

I like this as it doesn't smear and make my eyes dark. Goes on very well and soft.

This is OK as grays go, but it seems to have some sparkles in it which were not what I expected or wanted. I prefer the Prestige storm gray which apparently is not being made anymore, so am looking for a sub.

These eyeliners are awesome. My eyes are super sensitive to any type of waterproof makeup. Love these. They go on effortlessly and have a good selection of different colors