L'Oreal ParisMakeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner, Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant, Glides on Easily to Create any Look, Grey, 0.042 oz.

4 stars for how long this pencil lasts !!1 star off for the color of the pencil.See comment below:The PURPLE pencil eyeliner is NOT the same as the lght purple pencil you find in the stores. Or that is pictured here. I haven't even seen the color I received sold in stores... ever. Interesting 🤔Like... not even CLOSE.The purple liner sold here is a DARK purple. No... not the aubergine color. It is actually a dark violet purple. Not muddy purple, like the aubergine pencil.The color sold in stores and pictured here is a LIGHT LILAC color purple.Also this item is not returnable, so please keep that in mind as well!On the PLUS side... if you are looking for a dark royal purple eyeliner, (that does NOT last all day... and is similar to / as a dupe for Urban Decay's Psychedelic Sister dark purple pencil liner) that DOES last ALL DAY... then this violet color purple is definitely FOR YOU !! 💜

Started out liking this product, went on so smoothly, stayed in place, lasted all day. The shades of brown and aubergine are what impressed me. Then I ordered black, and my opinion changed. Went on smoothly etc..except after a few hours, I had racoon eyes! Only that color!! Also, these pencils are extremely hard to sharpen! Thinking of switching to a different brand that doesn't need a muscular arm to sharpen it every few uses.

Hands down, one of the best eyeliner lines on the market, drugstore or high end. You put it on, wait a few seconds to dry and IT ABSOLUTELY DOES NOT MOVE. This particular color really brings out my gray eyes but I've also tried other colors from this line (the dark grey and brown) and they are mind blowing as well - they absolutely don't move and they last the whole day. I first swatched them on my hand and it was like a having tattoo - until I used an oil-based cleanser to get it off. Still shocked that it's not high end.

I have this eyeliner in brown and aubergine and I love them both - great color and stays in place while still washing off fairly easily. Just not entirely sure why it doesn't twist up to sharpen when it feels like it should. They both do this so I'm assuming it's not broken. For a moment I thought I had spent almost 10 bucks on a week's worth of pencil...until I pulled the end off and used a nail to push it up further. I'm sure there's an easier way (I've read there's a specific sharpener made for this brand?) but this worked for me.

I really like how long it lasts

Great liner, but sharpening it wastes so much of it. I wish they made this in a twist stick (or whatever you call it). Would last far longer. And sharpening it leaves sharp jagged edges that poke and kind of hurt.

Love this ! Stays on all day , doesn’t smear ! They say L’Oréal and Lancôme are the same company decided to give it a chance and I was definitely pleased! Every eyeliner I’ve ever used except Lancôme runs , but it is expensive… this is a lifesaver! Love it !

I looked online for a product similar to the Clinique eye pencil and this was suggested. Love these pencils. I got one in each color and the price is incredible.

Mi pedido llegó en buen estado y es lo que pedí.Siempre me sorprenden, son muy rápidos.

Good but not good enough

Great eyeliner. Stays on and in place until it’s time to remove your makeup.

Quite a good product.

This goes on smooth and stays put. The colour is beautiful particularly if you have blue or green eyes!