BULLYSTICKS & MORE - Pork Collagen Rolls for Dogs (10-12" - 5 Count) - Made in USA - Pork Cheek Rolls for Dogs - Dog Parents Choice - Premium No Hide

Perfect for my bog dog (pit boxer mix). Keeps him busy when we need him to be an extra good boy. No stink to them, but they are a little sticky or greasy to the touch.

The 4 dogs loved them but 1 dog had to get a different treat as there was only 4 in the bag, not 5 as stated. I think I should get a refund or at least a new bag. That is why the 1 star.

Opening these up, I could definitely tell that they were what they had said they were. They have a very distinct smell!These sticks are quite huge, my 40 pound dog can nurse one of these for a few days Without any problems. I will say that she does seem to lose interest in them after a while, I’m not really sure why, but after the first two she has not really seemed like she’s wanted anymore beyond that. She will carry them around or hide them, but I don’t think she wants to chew on them anymore.I’m going to try re-introducing them in a while, I think she may have just eaten them too quickly!I do, especially appreciate that they are not messy, and that even when she just chew on them for long periods of time, I don’t find pieces throughout the house! So, not only are they durable, but they’re also not messy, which is a huge plus for me!

These are huge, and my dogs love them... very high protein treat, made in the USA. "Bully sticks"... I guess everybody uses that term very "loosely", because I always thought that meant a certain part of a bull, that will go unmentioned for now, but these are not that, these are straight "collagen" wraps... porcine... meaning from pigs. They are high in protein, they're high quality American sourced, and they're beneficial to support good health, as I understand it. The taste is obviously wonderful, and my dog knows to look at these as exceptional, fairly rare, treats..... he gets very serious ... you can see it in his eyes, right when he eyeballs one ...the whole world stops... obviously asking himself, he he dares believe his own eyes, fighting off the urge to pinch himself to make sure it's not a dream, besides, if it's a dream, he doesn't want to wake up, so he's dead focused..... I can see all of that in his eyes, yet he does not see me, at all.... he only sees a big, juicy, luscious, lip smackingly huge, delectable, hunk of animal cartilage, all rolled up nicely, to maximize eye appeal, and make it look as "daunting" and delicious, as possible... I mean, these things are big, did I mention that?...I'd almost swear I heard my dog mutter under his breath, in a kind of rumbling, low growl, but with clear English enunciation .... he seemed to distinctively say the word, "holy".... and then there was a second word, after holy, ..... I think it was "cow", although he has been hanging around with me since he was a little puppy... so, I don't know.... holy?.... molly!... that was it... yes, holy molly, that's the ticket. My dog then went on to say that these are "sourced and packed in the USA, which is very important when it comes to dog stuff". A smart dog he is. Even if he doesn't talk. He communicates, just fine.

I had several disappointments with these rolls.There was pooled yuck in the bag, which was bad enough that I decided I wasn’t going to buy from this brand again.The smell is horrible.They weren’t as chewy as they broke apart when the pups chewed. Was a bit worried about sharpness.One of my dogs seemed to struggle as she was farting a lot and had a brief stint of loose stool.My dogs didn’t seem to love them as much as other brands of collagen rolls.There are brands with more rolls for less money and my dogs love those.

Admittedly, my dog is a bit of a picky eater, and prefers chicken-flavored treats. This is the first treat I've tried to give her, however, that she has refused to try. She'll sniff one for a little bit, then walk away.The rolls in my 5 ct. package are about 10" long and roughly 1" to1-1/4" in diameter, and hollow. Each collagen roll is hard, like a rawhide, and slightly oily to the touch. They also have a slight chemical/acrid smell, which is probably what puts my dog off them.

My dog goes crazy for these. I try to limit them because they are really rich, but fantastic for an occasional treat

These arrived with intact packaging, however they were extremely greasy and smelled rancid. Upset there are no refunds on products that arrive in unacceptable condition. Will not purchase from this brand again.