Walker's Shortbread Festive Shapes Tin

Love these cookies! I ordered this holiday assortment for a gift and several of the shaped cookies were broken. They should have used more bubble wrap!!!

This container was in perfect shape on the outside. The plastic tray was broken and 3/4 of the cookies were in pieces. It was embarrassing because it was a hostess gift. 🙀. The 2nd box had a smashed tin and half the cookies were broken as well. It was a very expensive ($18/box) disappointment.

Cookies taste OK but they were shattered in transit. Now they’re good for 5 year olds but not appropriate for presentation

Walkers makes the best shortbread cookies in the world. The only complaint I would have for this gift tin is there were more than a few cookies broken, the cookies need to be vacuum sealed in place. shipping had the cookies broken and out of place, but they were still good to eat

Unfortunately most of the cookies are broken... I had originally bought this to put out with other things at thanksgiving for everyone to snack on as we have most of my mothers side of the family (immediate relations anyway) coming for the 4 day weekend. Having 19 people over a few days goes through a lot of food lol.... I will still offer these, although I am a bit disappointed at them all being broken. I knew it was risky ordering these though as I read through reviews beforehand... Walkers Shortbread is a stable favorite with most of the family, no matter what they prefer to drink with it as it goes well with both hot tea and coffee, or milk for the kids. I ordered the Walkers Mince Pies as well, for the first time, as we have a lot of mincemeat lovers in the family as well and I'm only making one mince pie to take as I will also be making a pecan pie, and a couple of pumpkin pies. Luckily they don't seem to be broken like the cookies. I am still rating 3 stars even though the cookies are a mess because the tin itself is in perfect shape, and the box they came in wasn't banged up so I think the fault lies with how the cookies are packed... There is just too much room for them to bounce around in the tray inside the tin and good shortbread cookies should break apart easily and basically melt in your mouth when eating! I love the tin (It's actually why I chose these over the regular shapes they offer) and plan on adding it to my holiday decor, which I don't normally do. I usually avoid anything that comes in a tin as I always feel guilty throwing them out and you can't keep them all! Lol... I will probably use it for more of their cookies next year, and just buy the ones I usually get (the "cookie fingers" brick shaped) to fill the tin as they don't ever seem to have issues getting broken as they are pack so tight together.... Anyway, love the tin! Love the flavor/texture of the cookies, they are the best when it comes to store bought shortbread in my opinion! We have tried everything sold around here and the only thing that comes close is homemade. If you want the tin, and don't mind if the cookies are broken then I say go for it! For those worried about sell by dates, mine say they are good until the end of November 2023, so no worries there.

These cookies are a must at our house at Christmas. They have a wonderful buttery taste. This tin arrived dented with more than half of the cookies broken so we ate them instead of gifting them to our neighbors

Let me start by saying, Walker's cookies are the most amazing cookies I have ever tried! So for the last 2 years I have gifting my staff this delightful tin of cookies. And they have loved it! Even the people whose cookies didn't survive the trip intact, they have said that it's the best cookie they have eaten! They said the flavor was heavenly and have begged to get the same gift every year for Christmas. It's a win win. The price is excellent for the amount of cookies you get and best of all, in a beautiful tin. So if the reviews about broken cookies make you think twice. Don't! Just warn the gift receiver they might be banged around a bit but the flavor makes everything worth it!

Arrived with all the “seasonal shapes” broken and stale tasting.