stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner

This product is awesome! I used it to draw vines on my face and arms for a Poison Ivy costume I wore to my trapeze class. So easy to apply and it stayed on relatively well, considering that I was moving a lot and I didn't use any barrier spray. It only really wiped off on my forehead when I brushed some sweat away. Otherwise, it stayed put. Good flow of color, and I love the tip because you can draw both thick and thin lines with it. I'll be using it for another costume this weekend. Definitely going to buy again once it's gone!

I have oily eyelids and for the very long time I have been looking for an eyeliner to stay on through the day and did smear under my eyes. I also like blue with a touch of grey. The one I was using for years was discontinued last year.Over a week ago I was reading lists of the best 2016 eyeliners and decided to order the stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner. As soon I received it tried it immediately. The blue is nice shade, went on smoothly and stayed the entire day without running, flaking and was easy to remove.

I got this Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner after watching a youtube video and had to have this amazing color. I was a bit skeptical as other other liquid liners I have used seem to stain the lid or creep/spread. Not this one - very tight line, fine point, and glides over lid (I did prime lid first). Since it is fine tip, you will need to go over if you are trying to achieve a thicker look. This doesn't warrant a removal of a star, but I thought this product would have been longer - more like pencil length, but it's about 5 inches. Either way, great color, great product, can't wait to use it this weekend!

50% Impressed • 50% DisappointedThe color is, as advertised, a very bright, eye catching, electric blue!50% of me was super impressed with the following: The vibrance of this "liquid" eye liner is pretty amazing, I'm not gonna lie. I haven't found a different liner that matches this product's color. It's almost neon when applied to a fair skin tone with minimal to zero makeup of any kind underneath it, which leads me to the other 50% of my not so positive review...50% of me was disappointed in this product because: I'm one of those girls, who either wears full makeup or no makeup at all, and bright blue eyeliner, in my world, requires the whole shebang, concealer, foundation, powder, eye shadow, blah blah blah. Once I finished applying my eye shadow, I went to put on the final touch with my new bangin' blue eye liner, and I was so completely devastated when I saw that this stuff does NOT play well with other makeup. It just completely refuses to go onto the skin (unless it's clean/makeup free skin). I tried everything, even switching eye shadow brands and types of eye shadows like, powders, creams, and gels, and after my 4th or 5th attempt, it was becoming obvious to me, that nothing I did was going to make this eye liner adhere to my skin on top of my eye makeup. Through all of my attempts to make this liner work with all sorts of different different eye shadow base types and brands, I noticed one thing was always the same, the felt tip of the eye liner pen drug through my eye shadow like a stick in the mud, pulling up all the previously applied makeup in it's path, like some sort of makeup eraser, which of course is the opposite effect of what I was going for, ugh. One of the last things I feel like I should mention, since we've come this far, is the act of calling this liner a "liquid" liner is somewhat inaccurate in my opinion, simply because the way the product is distributed through to the felt tip applicator pen...The liner isn't wet or liquid-y at all when it hits your skin, it's more like a 90% dried, sticky, or even tacky version of what was supposed to be liquid, but it dries up on it's way out of the pen before it even touches your skin. I think it's just sort of a bad design in my opinion, because it doesn't allow the product to come out fast enough, which causes other problems (as I mentioned above).The product would be so much better overall if they could redesign the applicator tip to release the product quicker so that it's still wet when it hits your skin. Such a shame, I was so excited for this bright blue eye liner to be everything I had hoped it would be, but now, the search for a colorfully vibrant liquid eyeliner continues! Oy vey!P.S. The "Smudge Stick Waterproof Eye Liner" by this same brand is amazing! I have only tried the black color, but I would highly recommend this product for all of you eyeliner junkies out there! It's the blackest black I've ever seen from a liner, and it makes tight lining your inner and bottom lids a breeze. Goes on super smooth, and stays pretty well throughout the day. However, I wouldn't agree with the "Waterproof" part, because if you cry, even a single drop, This liner, WILL run, but it's pretty sturdy for a pencil liner. Beware though, it is addicting, you wont want to use another pencil liner after this one, and it does tend to run out pretty quick, so order more than 1 at a time if you're like me, and NEED eye liner.Fin!

WARNING - this product is by no means waterproof. It runs constantly. I bought it in Moss, and every time I tried to use it I was left with green tracks down the crinkles on the side of my eyes within minutes of application and then throughout the day - extremely embarrassing, and totally unacceptable. Not waterproof, but IS very hard to remove when it runs, smudging the lines all over the sides of my face at work when I tried to clean up my eye make-up leaving me with ruined shadow as well as smudged liner. Returned it after trying it a few times and getting the same result each time.As a comparison, I was looking for a replacement for my beloved Lancôme Artliner in Forest - the color is now discontinued. Artliner IS a true waterproof liner, and has a similar felt tip for easy application. Artliner has never run on me, so I know that the problem is with the Stila product and not with my application. Going back to Artliner and will just try to find a color to use instead of Forest after this failed experiment with Stila.

I love this eyeliner. The liner is true to the color stated, and will stay on all day...all day. Many eyeliners I've used in the past have worn off by the end of the day. This one stays on until you take it off. And the tip makes it super easy to apply. It's the only kind I buy now.

I've tried other brands of eyeliner pens, but stilla has the perfect tip and formula. No itching or cracking and it is so precise. I use it to make leopard print patterns on my eyelid with no problem. Stays ALL day and into the next if you don't wash it off. Only problem is - they do dry out quick if you don't be careful.

I don't know why so many people love this product. It went on well for only a couple of weeks (and yes, I store it upside down), but it dries up and cracks off throughout the day. So would I put it on in the morning and get home in the evening with no eyeliner left. Harumph. The good: I wear blue eyeliner, and this shade of blue is beautiful and perfect.