It CosmeticsSuperhero No-Tug Retractable Eyeliner - All-Day Wear, Waterproof Formula Won’t Smudge - With Avocado Oil, Chamomile Extract, Vitamin E & Carnauba Wax - 0.008 oz

Love this eyeliner! It's the only one I've ever used that easily glides on smoothly and stays all day. I've gotten so many compliments on it and people asking what I use. I definitely prefer this twist version to the pencil, which often breaks towards the end when sharpening.

I love this eyeliner, goes on easy, no tugging, looks great, it is waterproof too.

The first one that as shipped to me came all smooshed in the cap. Processed the return and they shipped a new one immediately and I had it within 2 days. Perfect color for me. Stays put - no smudging, no weeping, no running - even when I cry + wipe with a tissue!

I am super impressed with this eyeliner! It goes on easily, says, and the sharpener at the bottom is a game changer. It's easy to sharpen and blend but it sets quickly so be ready to work your beauty magic right as soon as possible. I ordered the classic black color and it doesn't smudge but it does irritate my eyes (I have very sensitive/combination skin). It doesn't irritate me enough to stop using it, but if you're like me, be careful while applying and have eye drops hand ;).

Eyeliner is easy to apply, lasts until removed with soap and water.

Best ever!!

Doesn’t pull and doesn’t break off, which I love. Rich deep color.

It definitely smudges and isn't waterproof. When you put it on initially it glides easily and looks fantastic, but within an hour it was already starting to smudge just from heat. I wanted to try it because it's described as "waterproof & smudge proof" which are both false. Paying $25 for eyeliner is bad enough but it's even worse when it doesn't live up to its own description. 🤷🏻‍♀️