L'Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Pro-Last Pencil Eyeliner, Waterproof and Smudge-Resistant, Glides on Easily to Create any Look, Cobalt Blue, 0.042 oz.

This is a good, hardy eyeliner pencil, the kind that you sharpen with a separate sharpener-- not those flimsy ones that you have to turn up, that break all the time. The thickness is perfect, stays put, doesn't smudge, and goes on smooth. I rarely see this one in stores, so I was really happy to find one on here to replace the one I had previously used up. I hope they never stop making this one, because a good eyeliner with all of these qualities is hard to find!

This is the best eyeliner, I have chronic watery eyes, and this is actually water resistant. What I love about it though is that it can still be removed easily if applied incorrectly/wrong spot. Gorgeous on light eyes!

TIGHTLINE PROCEDURE: applied, then opened eyes wide with little blinking for 1 minute.COLOR: very nice, deep purple (no sparkle or metallic tinges). The color rivaled but wasn't as rich as Urban Decay 24/7. (But UD smudged on my hooded, extremely oily eyes & disappeared by the end of the day.)NO SMUDGING: woo hoooo! No smudging on top or below eyes throughout the day. Some fading, but not marked. I don't ever re-apply so more than enough color left to make me happy.REMOVAL: with Neutrogena Oil-Free Makeup Remover on a cotton pad, I gently press it on my eyelid & then with the pad, roll my upper lid just ever so slightly & keep the pad on the tightlined area for a few seconds. After, I wait 20-30 seconds, and then swipe several times with the pad again. This removes all or most of the liner. I wouldn't qualify this as an easy to remove liner, but it's easy enough given the all-day wear. Also, for perspective, I do not wear mascara.Lastly, I don't wear contacts so I can't speak to whether this liner would cause irritation.DEFINITELY HG! I'm a relative minimalist with makeup. 5-10 minutes at most with SPF, pressed powder, loose powder, lite blush, eyebrows, & tightline liner. Because of its outstanding color & all-day staying power (into 9-10 pm), it's easily become my HG liner!

I love the abergine/plum color. A little soft so slides on nicely but point doesn’t stay pointy for long which is okay since I use on top lid as a thicker line like a stick shadow under my L'Oreal Paris Lineur Intense Felt Tip Liquid Eyeliner, Carbon Black. Sharpens well (bought the Sun's Out Beauty Precision 2-in-1 Cosmetic Pencil Sharpener) . Sometimes clumps when applying close to lashes under eye which is annoying (so took off 1 star) but I use finger to smooth. Stays on all day. Fair price compared to more expensive brands.

I love this eyeliner. It goes on smooth and look great. I have ordered it before and have multiple colors. This is the only eyeliner I buy. It is not wet but does on dry ad does not smudge.

I have bought this twice. The first one wouldn’t extend once I unused it. I twisted the end and nothing. So I fired it was a fluke and ordered the same one a second time. Same issue. Could be user error, but I’ve seen others make the same comment so it isn’t just me. If it is user error, it shouldn’t be this difficult to figure out. It’s eyeliner, not a rocket. You use it, then you twist to get more to come out. Should be that simple. But not this one. 🤷‍♀️

I really like the color a lot. I like the ease of how it goes on and it lasts a few hours. But it's easily used up in one application. It has to be sharpened every time. I do not like the fact that it is too soft and breaks off easily in my pencil sharpener. The pencil itself did not last long at all and was used up really fast. It would be great if they could make it a roll-up eyeliner instead.

I love this lipstick. It lipped my lips very well. The stick was very good. It had a nice lip taste. It blended very lip like. And it pigmented like a lipstick. It was a nice lip texture. And the length was great. Very nice and tasty will try again.